Meathead's Favorite Commercial Barbecue Sauces, Spice Rubs, Steak Sauces, and More
The first commercial barbecue sauce was made by H.J. Heinz Co. in 1948, and today there are hundreds. It seems every ribjoint is bottling its signature sauce nowadays.
Likewise, every serious home barbecuer's gotta have a signature sauce or three. One that your neighbor doesn't have. One that's not in every grocery store in town.
I prefer to make my own sauces from the recipes on this site, but I do love tasting commercial sauces (heck, reverse engineering them is how I get my best recipes), and, well, don't tell anyone, but I've been known to "doctor" a commercial sauce and rebottle it in an unlabeled jelly jar. If my guests want to think I made it from scratch, well, I can't control what they think.
I taste a LOT of commercial barbecue sauces and I even have a scorecard for rating them. Below are some of my favorites. All of them rate 3 1/2 to 4 bones on my 4 bone scale. I've attempted to group them by style. Click here for a deeper discussion of the classic American BBQ sauce styles.
Saucing strategies
There's a trick to using barbecue sauce, especially if it's sweet. What's the trick? Click here.
Product Reviews and Meathead's Hot Stuff Awards
These are highly recommended products that I have tested personally or that have been tested by reliable sources. Awards are based on features, quality, and value. Rest assured that when I recommend a product, it is really because I like it, not because someone has paid me to say so or because the company is an advertiser or sponsor. I purchase most products I review although occasionally suppliers send me samples.
Manufacturers: Contact Meathead for permission to use this award medallion and to get a high resolution version.
Shopping tip
When a product is available on Amazon.com, I often provide a direct link. Amazon.com often has the best prices anywhere, even better than many manufacturers' websites. That's because manufacturers know that if they undercut retailers, these important resellers may drop their products.
Full disclosure:Amazon.com pays me a small finder's fee when you purchase from them after clicking on a link here, so purchasing from them helps underwrite the cost of operating AmazingRibs.com. But low prices, fast delivery, and good refund policies are the real reasons to buy from Amazon.com. In fact, if you like all the info I give you for free and would like to help me buy charcoal, copy this url link and bookmark it: http://tinyurl.com/yazmwlq
It takes you to Amazon.com and tags anything you buy with my code so I get that small commission. It works on anything from grills to diapers and it has zero impact on the price you pay.
Dry Rubs
Rendezvous Famous Seasoning(Memphis, TN). Charlie Vergos' famed Rendezvous Restaurant in Memphis is renowned the world around for its "dry" ribs, served with no sauce, only this complex spice blend which includes paprika, chili powder, garlic, black pepper, salt, onion powder, oregano, thyme, celery seed, cayenne pepper, coriander, and who knows what else. You've gotta have a good spice blend to pull this off.
Blues Hog Dry Rub Seasoning(Perry, MO). Unmatched in complexity and balance, this is by far my favorite rub in the world. It has salt, important for pulling flavors into the meat, sugar, important for enhancing the natural meat flavors and helping for the crust on the meat, paprika, for color and richness, chili powder, black pepper, mustard, for heat, onion, garlic, ginger, cumin, and green herbs for complexity. Perfect for pork and beef.
Texas Rib Rangers Rosemary & Herb Seasoning(Denton, TX). The standard barbecue rubs are red from paprika and chili powder. This one is loaded with green things like basil, rosemary, oregano, marjoram, and bay leaves along with the necessary garlic, onion, salt. There is also a noticeable kick from red pepper balanced by sugar. It is great on pork chops, chicken, turkey, and even pork shoulders. Try rubbing up a pork loin with this stuff and wear your seatbelt at the dining table.
New York Steakhouse Cookout Companions. When it comes to steak, connoisseurs genuflect towards Texas and Chicago. I live in Chicago, so it is with heavy heart that I say "I'll take Manhattan", where the fabled and expensive steakhouses are the best in the world. Most steaks are best eaten naked, but if you want to kick it up a notch, several have developed manly sauces that add a layer of interest to their meats. The New York First Company has packaged five distinctive sauces from some of the nation's cathedrals of beef: Smith & Wollensky, Frankie & Johnnie's, Ben Benson's, Uncle Jack's, and Ottomanelli's, New York's venerable butcher shop.
Country Bob's All Purpose Sauce. Country Bob may call this an "all purpose" sauce but it's a steak and burger sauce to me, and it's a durn good one at that. Far less salty than than A1 and Lawry's, it is a bit thinner and sweeter, but it is also more flavorful. I rarely put a sauce on steak, but if you try Country Bob's on burgers instead of ketchup, you may never go back. I have also used it as an ingredient in some of my sauce recipes and it works just fine.
In 1958, John "Big Daddy" Bishop opened the Dreamland Café in Tuscaloosa, AL, the same year legendary football Coach Paul "Bear" Bryant arrived in Tuscaloosa. The ribs ascended to legendary, cooked fast but cooled with their thin flavorful sauce. The base is mostly vinegar and water, rounded out with tomato paste and mustard so it is a pale runny orange color that penetrates the meat and doesn't just squat on it. The taste is tangy, tart, with a noticeable hot pepper spice that lingers looooonnng. It is more like a Lexington Dip than anything else. Not everyone will like this one, but I love it.
El Gringo Mexican Barbeque Fusion(Warrenville, IL). Another winner from the creative kitchen of Chef Rick Kazdan. As is his style, it is rich, thick and complex, and although it comes from a Chicago burb, it tastes Mexican. There's molasses, honey, tamarind, chopped garlic, vinegar, chipotles in adobo, and other goodies held together by ketchup and tomato paste. It is a great balance of sweet and tart and hot. Try it on ribs, chicken, or anything else on which you'd put a tomato based barbecue sauce.
El Gringo Loco Sweet Island Heat(Warrenville, IL). Rick Kazdan calls his enterprise a "micro salsaria" because it is small, and his sauces are handcrafted, like a micro brewery. I'll buy that. At the moment he sells them mostly online and at farmer's markets around Chicago. I'm hoping he can grow beyond that. Sweet Island Heat is made in the tropical islands just west of Chicago, but one taste and you'd swear you were in Jamaica, mon. It is amber in color, thick as jam, chunky, flecked with herbs and spices, and shiny. It's really a chutney in my book. Ginger jumps out as soon as you open the jar, and when you get it in your mouth it explodes with tropical flavors like pineapple, orange, mango, and garlic, underpinned by a decent but not overbearing kick from jerk seasoning, chili sauce, and habanero puree. The ingredient list says there's also apple juice, grape juice, onion, and even banana. I like it as a dipping sauce for anything fried, especially chicken, fish, or samosas. Lately I've been dipping pretzel rods in the convenient wide mouth jar.
Tristan Chocolate Chili BBQ Sauce (Charleston, SC). As you might expect, this thick dark brown sauce hits you with a clean cocoa scent as soon as you open the bottle. A rich dark brown chocolate flavor dominates, and it is sweet, but it is surprisingly balanced with rice wine vinegar, chipotle and pasilla peppers, and orange juice. But you don't taste them, they nestle quietly into the background behind the bold chocolate. I like to amp it up with Chipotle Tabasco sauce.
Charlie Trotter's Organic Thai Barbecue Sauce (Chicago, IL). Forget everything you know about barbecue sauce. The great iconoclast chef has crafted this sweet, raisiny, citrusy sauce with sesame oil undertones and only a hint of heat for fish. Exquisite. Known for crafting unusual combinations of flavor, Trotter is often listed as one of the 10 greatest chefs in the nation and his Chicago restaurant is booked months in advance. Now you can bring a taste of Trotter to your next cookout.
Johnny V's Barbecue Sauce (Chicago, IL). Made in a Chicago suburb by Johnny Vogel (he is not connected to the popular Ft. Lauderdale restaurant named Johnny V's), this shiny, thick brown sauce has a dominant flavor: G-A-R-L-I-C. It is rich, strong, smoky, and even has clumps of garlic floating in it. A bit salty, there is a nice black pepper tang in the background and a looooonnnnng garlicky finish. Here's something I've never seen before: One of the ingredients is sweet potato! Did I mention there is a strong garlic aroma? Let's call it KC style with an Italian accent. I like it on burgers as well as my ribs. It is sold only in stores around Chicago.
Sweet Glaze
Blues Hog Barbecue Sauce (Perry, MO). A thoroughly creative and unusual sauce from the middle of nowhere in Perry, Missouri. Bill Arnold has crafted this intriguing sauce from practically every herb and spice on his rack. Garnet colored, runny at room temp and thick from the fridge, it is laden with flecks of black pepper, green herbs, mustard seeds, chile peppers, a generous hit of cumin, and all manner of edible grit. Actually more of a glaze, it varnishes your meat with a glossy sheen and deep sea complexity. A bit too sweet (brown sugar is the first item on the ingredients list), it is not unctuous because there are layers of red pepper heat, black pepper bite, nutty garlic, and grassy herbaceousness. It made my ribs sing, and try as I might, I have been unable to duplicate it. One word or warning: Because it is so sweet, use only one layer. Multiple coats is too much. The best source for Blues Hog products is Hawgeyes BBQ in Ankeny, Iowa. By the way, Hawgeyes is also a great source for other hard to find sauces, rubs, cookers, and all things barbecue. In 2007 it won top prize at the American Royal Sauce Championship in Kansas City.
Buz and Ned's Rib & Chicken Glaze(Richmond, VA). This place has cred. Buz himself whupped Bobby Flay in a ribs throwdown on FoodTV. So I had high hopes when I tasted his barbecue sauces. Sadly, I was a bit disappointed at first. The Real Barbecue Sauce was very good, but didn't bowl me over. The Glaze intrigued me because it was a dark garnet, ultra thick and rich, grainy with spices, but some how it did not send me. Perhaps because it was so tomatoey and that made it different than my expectations. Then one night we were making a meatloaf and there wasn't enough time to make a glaze. So I grabbed Buz And Ned's Glaze, and boy did it blow me away.
I have come to a conclusion about this stuff, and Buz is not gonna like hearing this, but it is the world's best ketchup. By far. Ketchup is tomato paste with vinegar, herbs, spices, and sweetener. Tomato-based barbecue sauce is usually ketchup with more of the same. So really, Kansas City style sauces are just amped up ketchups. The big diff is that ketchup is tomatoey, and barbecue sauce is less so. Well this stuff is tomatoey, and it is incredible on burgers, fries, meatloaf, and everything I love ketchup on.
Kansas City Style BBQ Sauce
Arthur Bryant's Sweet Heat Barbecue Sauce (Kansas City, MO). Almost orange colored, this sauce is mild, simple, understated. Designed to let the meat come to the fore. A delicate sweetness with a distinct fresh tomato flavor and a gentle heat in the finish than builds slowly and gently. Not a show-off. If you are looking for the rich molasses, smoky sauce that comes to mind when someone says KC barbecue, try one of the others.
Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q Championship Red Sauce (Decatur, AL). A first-rate Kansas City style sauce from Alabama. This multiple award winner is medium thick with some chunky stuff, giving it the feeling of a home-made brew. Orange-brown and just spicy enough to be hot without burning, it's sweet without being cloying, thanks to a citrusy tanginess, a smoky quality, and other complex undertones. Close your eyes and think of the great classic American barbecue sauce. If you look closely the label says Big Bob Gibson Championship Red.
Cookshack Spicy Barbecue Sauce(Ponca City, OK). Known for their high end electric smokers, Cookshack also makes some pretty fine rubs and sauces. Buy a Smokette for $465 and they throw in a bottle of sauce and two different rubs. It's a classic Kansas City style sauce. Nice garnet color, medium thick, not too sweet, not too tart, not too hot, it's perfectly balanced.
Lotta Bull BBQ Original BBQ Sauce (Marietta, OK). is from Mike & Debbie Davis of Marietta, OK. They are one of the top teams on the circuit and have probably won more prize money than anyone. A portion of the credit must go to their slightly sweet, slightly peppery, Kansas City style sauce. Not too thick, not too runny, not too anything, it is perfectly balanced. When I close my eyes and visualize the classic American barbecue sauce, this is what I taste.
Rufus Teague Honey Sweet BBQ Sauce (Kansas City, MO). A shiny mahogany color with orange edges, this medium thick sauce is KC Masterpiece on steroids. Rich with molasses and smoke, it is very complex and complete. No wonder, the ingredient list includes raisins, orange juice, anchovy, soy sauce, Worcestershire sauce, "and other spices you can't know about".
Sweet Baby Ray's(Chicago, IL) is of the three top-selling barbecue sauces in the country (some sources say it is #1) because it has everything the public loves. It is sweet, smoky, sweet, tangy but not too tangy, spicy but not too spicy, and, did I mention that it was smoky and sweet? It crisps nicely on the grill, but it can blacken easily if you don't watch out. Because it has a lot of liquid smoke flavor it tastes outdoorsy. If you use real wood to flavor your food, you do not need a sauce like this, and in fact, I find it too smoky for smoked meat. But if you do not use wood chips/chunks/pellets when you cook, or if you cook your ribs in the oven, it is perfect.
Texas Rib Rangers Barbeque Sauce Sweet Mild - Blue Label (Denton, TX). Everything you love about rich tomatoey Kansas City-style barbecue sauce is here. Sweet, but not so sweet that it kills the meat, tangy but not too tart, spicy but by no means hot, smoky but not ash tray, and complex with undertones of garlic, onion, and molasses. Just about perfect. This sauce is made by Bill & Barbara Milroy of Denton, TX, perennial champions on the barbecue competition circuit and barbecue instructors who have taught hundreds how to cook real barbecue.
The Slabs Kyle Style BBQ Sauce (Lone Jack, MO). Made in a suburb of Kansas City, this is a classic from one of the top teams on the competition circuit. Thick and brown with golden edges, there are black pepper chunks clearly visible, and it is grainy in the mouth, definite sweetness that is not enough to make it gooey, a hint of cumin, complex, with a long black pepper finish.
Three Little Pigs Competition BBQ Sauce (Independence, MO). Dark mahogany color, medium thickness. Molasses and smokiness jump to the nose followed quickly by garlic. There is a nice tomato base and distinct tartness followed by a mild lingering warmth.
South Carolina Yellow Mustard BBQ Sauce
Ole Ray's Classic Gold (St. Augustine, FL). Ray and Susan Greene are master barbecue sauciers. They make six and I rate the three that I've tasted at the top of my scale. One of my faves is this mustard based sauce. Developed by German immigrants in South Carolina, mustard sauces are perfect on pork, and they put it on everything in the Palmetto State. Forget those tomato-based sauces, there is nothing better on pulled pork than mustard sauce. This one is typical. Greenish gold, thin, and mildly sweet, there is a subtle black pepper heat that builds in the finish. Close your eyes and in the background you can taste vinegar, Worcestershire, honey, garlic, onion, and chili peppers. This is much more than ballpark mustard, but try it on hot dogs, anyway!
Shealy's Bar-B-Que Sauce (Leesville, SC). This is the prototypical South Carolina mustard sauce. Bright yellow, sweet and sour, with a loooonnng mustard finish. Some others have a lot of fancy herbs and spices, and that's nice, but Shealy has it right, a little ketchup, a little Worcestershire, and a little molasses. If you've never had a mustard sauce on barbecue pork, you don't know what you're missing. The combo is like peanut butter and jelly. It doesn't create a sheen like the sweeter sauces, but it really enhances flavor. And it's great on hot dogs, too.
Sticky Fingers Carolina Classic(Charleston, SC). Created by the Sticky Fingers restaurant chain that began near Charleston, SC, this is the prototypical yellow mustard, South Carolina-style sauce. Almost orange colored, it is thin, straightforward, simple, and strongly mustardy, with a nice lingering black pepper back taste and finish. Sticky Fingers makes a number of nice sauces, but this is my favorite. Todd Eischeid, Jeff Goldstein. and Chad Walldorf knew each other since 7th grade. One summer day when they were in college they made a pact to start a business together. They now have more than a dozen locations and are growing steadily. I think the sauces are their secret.
Thomas Bessinger's Spicy Golden Recipe Bar-Be-Que Sauce (Charleston, SC). Golden with red and black flecks, this is a really good yellow mustard sauce amped up with hot pepper sauce. Not too sweet, not too tart, not too hot, but if you don't like a little heat, get another one. I think it is perfect for pulled pork.
East Carolina Mop & Sauce
Scott's Barbecue Sauce (Goldsboro, NC). Prototypical Eastern North Carolina mop and sauce with nothing but vinegar, salt, peppers, and a few other spices. Tangy from the cider (??) vinegar, it does a great job of cutting the fat. Spicy, but not scorchin'. This is the kind of stuff that made North Carolina barbecue famous.
Lexington Mop & Sauce
Bone Suckin' BBQ Sauce "Thicker Style"(Raleigh, NC). Bottled in a jelly jar, this shiny garnet colored sauce is chunky with what are probably green jalapeño pepper bits. It has a slightly sweet, fresh tomato undercarriage, with a great balance of sweet-heat-tart components. Though it is from Raleigh, NC, this is not your typical North Carolina sauce. Available in gallon and half gallon jugs.
George's Original Barbecue Sauce(Nashville, NC). A classic Lexington style sauce made in nearby Nashville, NC, George's is mostly vinegar laced with hot red pepper, black pepper, and a whisp of ketchup. A touch of apple juice rounds it out nicely, making it my favorite of this style. It's among my first choices for pulled pork. If you like vinegar, you'll love George's. Definitely not for everyone.
Sam Dillard's Bar-B-Q Sauce (Durham, NC). A pale amber color with red and white flecks, this thin sauce is a light vinegar sauce, but not nearly as acidic as the East Carolina sauces because it is slightly diluted and has a bit of tomato concentrate to mellow it. There are plenty of spices, but it is not very hot. This is not meant to steal the show, just deliver some pleasant spices to the meat.
Alabama White Sauce
Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q Original White Sauce (Decatur, AL). This is not what everyone thinks of when they think of barbecue sauce. It is white, first of all. And it is not sweet. It almost like a salad dressing and it is especially formulated for smoked chicken. Mayonnaise dominates, followed by mustard, black pepper, and vinegar. Not everyone likes it. But it's a classic and worth a try if you love barbecue. If you don't like it on chicken, it's just fine on coleslaw.
Texas Mop Sauces
Cooper's BBQ Sauce(Lano, TX). The best Texas barbecue sauce is a puzzlement. It is made to complement beef brisket. It is at all not sweet, it is thin, more like a gravy or a thin tomato soup than a sauce, heavily spiked with vinegary tartness, a splash of hot sauce, and probably flavored with chili or ancho powder, black pepper, cumin, onion, and garlic. It easily penetrates the meat rather than sitting on top.
The problem is that the stuff in the bottle is nothing like the stuff you get served at the pit. The picture here shows the sauce bucket at Cooper's sitting on the pit where they hold meats for customers to select. They start by dumping their bottled sauce in the bucket in the morning, and as the day goes by, the trimmings go in, and if you want sauce on your meat, it is dunked in the bucket. Before long it tastes a LOT different than the bottled stuff. Doesn't that look good enough to jump in to? So don't expect bottled Texas sauces to taste at all like this because they don't have the trimmings and drippings. Now there are plenty of good sauces in Texas, among my faves are those by Texas Rib Rangers recommended elsewhere on this page, but they are really more Kansas City style than Texas style.
To come close to the real deal, you could blend a good beef stock with the bottled sauce, or perhaps some drippings from a roast beef. You can come close by starting from scratch with my Texas BBQ Juice recipe.
To make things worse, Cooper's has a minimum purchase on their website so you just can't order a bottle. If you're tempted, add a brisket onto your order.
Whiskey Sauce
Dr. Dan's BBQ Sauce Magical Meat Elixir, Kentucky Bourbon(Springfield, OH). Dr. Dan has made this boozy brown, medium-thick elixir by starting with his very rich and nuanced "Original Formula" sauce and adding extract of Bourbon (sorry, there's no alcohol in it, so it's safe for the kiddies). Try it on beef brisket or venison.
Fruit Based Sauces
Ole Ray's Blackberry Wine Barbecue & Cooking Sauce (St. Augustine, FL). A thick dark brown glop whose fruity flavor from blackberry jelly and wine has multiple dimensions from smoke flavor, a mild pepper kick, and good crisp acidity from vinegar and lemon juice. This is not a novelty sauce. It has real richness and depth. I am also a big fan of the Ole Ray's Apple/Cinnamon Barbeque Sauce, a KC style red sauce with a distinct apple note and a long layered heat in the finish.
AmazingRibs.com is all about the Zen of Barbecue, cooking ribs, and all kinds of BBQ recipes and techniques: Barbecue baby back ribs, spare ribs, pulled pork, beef brisket, chicken, smoked turkey, steak, lamb, barbecue sauces, rubs, and great side dishes, with the net's best buying guide to barbecue smokers and cookers. It is written, illustrated, and coded solely by Craig "Meathead" Goldwyn.
Product Reviews and Meathead's Hot Stuff Awards. Meathead's Hot Stuff Awards are highly recommended products that I have tested personally or that have been tested by reliable sources. Awards are based on features, quality, and value. Rest assured that when I recommend a product, it is really because I like it, not because someone has paid me to say so or because the company is an advertiser or sponsor. I purchase most products I review although occasionally suppliers send me samples.
About links on this site. Other than clearly marked ads, links and recommendations on this site are all products, services, and websites I truly admire, and are never paid endorsements. Your suggestions are always welcome. If you would like me to link to your website, click here to read my links policy first.
My Privacy Promise.I promise to never sell or distribute any info about you individually without your express permission, and I promise not to, ahem, pepper you with email or make you eat spam. Click here for more about my privacy promise.
This link takes you to Amazon.com and tags anything you buy with my affiliate code so I get a small referral fee. It works on anything from grills to diapers and it has zero impact on the price you pay. Low prices, fast delivery, and good refund policies are the best reasons to buy from Amazon.com, but clicking on that link before you shop helps me devote more time and money to you. Thanks!
Meathead's Faves
These recommendations are not ads. They are unsolicited endorsements.
GrillGrates Take Your Grill Into the Infrared Zone
GrillGrates are the best new product I have tested in years and the best thing to happen to beef since salt and pepper.
They sit on top of your current grill's grates. The hard anodized aircraft grade aluminum rail tops are flat and wide and make perfect dark crunchy grill marks. The base superheats yet eliminates hot spots and blocks flareups. This is the same concept behind the expensive new infrared grills.
Juices drip in the valleys between the rails and are vaporized and penetrate the meat enhancing flavor. I throw wood between the rails and they impart a delicate smoke flavor. I have made my best steaks and burgers ever with Grill Grates. This is a really great new product! Click here to read more and for ordering info.
The Smokenator
If you have a Weber Kettle, you need the amazing Smokenator and Hovergrill. The Smokenator turns your grill into a first class smoker, and the Hovergrill can add capacity or be used to get steakhouse steaks. Click here to read more and for ordering info.