How to Buy the Best In-Food And In-Cooker Thermometer

In addition to the must-have instant read thermometer, an in-food/in-cooker (IFIC) thermometer should be part of every chef's collection of tools. Why have both, you might ask? While the instant read might provide the final say as to doneness, the in-food/in-cooker unit provides a real-time progress report on the status of the cooking session. An instant read cannot be left inserted in the food while it is cooking, so you only have a readout while you're inserting the probe into the food. An IFIC, on the other hand, remains inserted during the entire cooking session, displaying the temperatures of the food(s) and the cooker simultaneously.

While all IFICs do pretty much the same thing - display real-time temperatures measured by cabled probes - they differ in how they present the information to the cook. At the most basic level, the temperature of one or more probes is displayed on a control box into which the probe cables plug. This is adequate if the cooker is located in close proximity to the cook. If not, there are several varieties of wireless remote units available. Some come with a dedicated remote that communicates with the control box. Others communicate with a smart phone via Bluetooth, but range can be a problem. At the highest level, the control box communicates with the cook's Wi-Fi router, making the temperature data available, via the cloud, on a smart device or browser anywhere an internet connection is available. Your proximity to the cooker and how immediately you need temperature feedback will determine which of these categories is most appropriate for your needs.

Some IFICs have only a single temperature probe and others have six or eight. It's nice to have a readout of the cooker's temperature in addition to the food's temperature, especially if you're dealing with a smoker whose temperature might vary considerably over a long period. With the cooker's temp covered, ask yourself how many pieces of food you'll want to monitor, and use that as a guide to how many probe channels you'll need.

All IFICs that I've seen allow you to set alarms, frequently an upper and lower value, that will alert you to wayward cooker temps or food nearing completion. Most alarms are an audible/visual signal displayed on the control box, the remote, or on your smartphone. Many units have pre-programmed temperature values for different levels of doneness for different types of meat or you can set your own values. Most pre-programmed temperatures conform to the USDA standards, values that would usually result in overcooked food. The choice is yours. For an overview of safe doneness temperatures, see our award-winning temperature guide here.

Most smartphone apps present the same info: temperature, alarm settings, and a temperature vs. time graph for each probe. The graphs are helpful in determining the onset of the stall. Some are more intuitive to navigate than others. Many allow you to save or download the graphical data; you'll have to decide how important that is to you. (I use such data when testing thermostatic controllers.)

Most IFICs operate on batteries, although some require an AC power source. Think about the availability of power at your cooker if considering the latter category.

As with instant reads, quality of construction and resistance to moisture are considerations. Cheaper units often aren't designed and built to survive a rainstorm, something to think about if you're planning to use the control box outdoors.

Prioritize your needs then use our database to find a highly-rated product to fill them. 

Placeholder
The Meatstick Wi-Fi-Bluetooth Food Thermometer is a tool that allows a wireless temperature probe to communicate with a smart phone to monitor cooking progress. read more
Placeholder
FireBoard has set a new standard in food thermometry. It is a remote read, cloud connected, data logger, with connections for up to six probes. It can communicate with a smart phone via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi to monitor the temps of both cooker and food. It received our top rating for its full feature set and performance. read more
Placeholder
See the complete review of the ET-733 Redi-Check, a dual-probe transmitter/receiver designed for food and oven monitoring from a remote location. We gave it a Gold Medal for great performance and a full feature set. read more
Placeholder
The Thermoworks Chef Alarm is a leave-in-food or leave-in-oven thermometer. The display unit remains outside the cooker and displays the probe temperature, min and max temperatures, upper and lower alarm settings and has a count-down timer function. It gets a top rating for its construction, features and performance. read more
Placeholder
The Maverick XR-50 is an extended-range, four-channel wireless remote food and cooker thermometer. It ships with two straight 6" probes and two straight 3" probes. It is well constructed with a robust case and heavy-duty probes, so it should stand up well. Wins a solid top rating for performance and construction. read more
Placeholder
The ThermoWorks "Smoke," is a two-channel, in-food/in-oven, wireless remote thermometer that is well made, easy to use, and performs very well. It has a transmitter attached to two probes and a remote receiver that you can put in your pocket. It can be operated over the Internet using the Gateway. A solid top rating! read more
Placeholder
See our complete review of the Tappecue Touch, a four-channel, Internet-enabled wireless food thermometer, that got a Gold Medal. read more
Placeholder
Here's the full report on the ThermoWorks ThermaQ, a high-quality readout, using Type K thermocouple probes for someone looking for a rugged instrument that can be used in many ways. We gave this a Gold Medal for its rugged construction, versatility, and performance. read more
Placeholder
The Meater Block is a novel approach to the wireless temperature measurement product category. While most competing products employ temperature probes tethered to a transmitter by a braided wire, the Meater builds the transmitter and battery to power it into the probe itself. read more
Placeholder
Read our thorough review of the InkBird IBT-4XS, a four-channel, Bluetooth-enabled wireless thermometer that communicates with smartphone applications, either Apple or Android. We gave it a Silver Medal for good performance. read more
Placeholder
Read our analysis of the Tappecue, an innovative product for monitoring up to four temperatures anywhere Internet access is available. We gave it a Bronze Medal. read more
Placeholder
Read our thorough review of the Rock's Stoker II, a significantly improved version of the original Stoker with new features and much better performance. This one gets a Gold Medal. read more
Placeholder
Read our review of the ET-736, Maverick’s latest entry into the remote thermometer market, and follows the very successful ET-732 and ET-733 wireless models. This unit falls short in terms of performance and features, and we do not recommend it. read more
Placeholder
Read our analysis of the Maverick ET-75, a remote unit designed to mount on a turning rotisserie and read the internal temperature of the meat. We do not recommend this product. read more
Placeholder
The CyberQ Cloud is BBQ Guru's new entry into the remote thermostatic controller market intended for use on charcoal grills or smokers. It adds a cloud connection that allows monitoring and setting most control functions from anywhere an Internet connection is available, using a browser or app. It gets our top rating. read more

Pages

Placeholder

Bill McGrath

Bill McGrath is AmazingRibs.com's Thermometer Maven. He has sophisticated equipment, an electrical engineering degree from Cornell University, and an MBA (almost) from UC Berkeley. Despite being mostly retired, he is still the person responsible for developing and updating all of ExxonMobil's electricians' training modules.

Search Our Ratings and Reviews

Click Search to see all our Reviews and Ratings. Use the filters below to refine your search.

 

 

 

Placeholder

Related articles

Placeholder

Placeholder

Many merchants pay us a small referral fee when you click our links and purchase from them. On Amazon it works on everything from grills to diapers, they never tell us what you bought, and it has zero impact on the price you pay, but has a major impact on our ability to improve this site! And remember, we only recommend products we love. If you like AmazingRibs.com, please save this link and use it every time you go to Amazonhttps://tinyurl.com/amazingribs

Placeholder

Placeholder

Get Smoke Signals, our free e-letter. No spam. Guaranteed

Enter your email:

Placeholder

Placeholder


Post comments and questions below

Placeholder

1) Try to post your question to the appropriate page.

2) Tell us everything we need to know to help such as the type of cooker and thermometer. Dial thermometers are often off by as much as 50°F so if you are not using a good digital thermometer we probably can't help you with time and temp questions. Please read this article about thermometers.

3) If you are a member of the Pitmaster Club, your comments login is probably different than your membership login.

Moderators

 

Click to ask questions and make comments